@LizHurra Note that new evidence has since emerged that unequivocally implicates an opposition faction, including verified video of them executing the attack.
x.com/Rootclaim/stat…
Today we announce the resolution of a major controversy: Who was behind the 2013 chemical attack near Damascus?
Many in the West blamed the Syrian government, while Syria and its allies claimed a “false flag” opposition attack, intended to bring about US intervention.
Note that we calculated the expected prevalence among blood donors and found the zero samples evidence to fit both hypotheses well. The blood bank study is therefore not evidence for either hypothesis.
from here: blog.rootclaim.com/covid-origins-…
[Claim:] “30,000 people donated blood in autumn 2019, and the hospitals still had most of it. So they tested the blood samples for COVID antibodies and didn’t find any… There are 12 million people in Wuhan, so if even a few hundred people had COVID during that time, one of them should have turned up. None of them did.”
[Rootclaim response:]
This is missing two important factors:
We need to give 1-2 weeks for antibodies to develop.
People are not allowed (and don’t want) to donate blood until feeling well.
That means this whole sample is delayed by around 3 weeks. So let’s see what zero positive blood samples tell us:
We have 44,000 samples 1-Sep to 31-Dec.
Since infections more than double every week, almost all the positives will fall on the last week. That’s 44000/13=3400 samples or 1 in 3000 Wuhan residents.
So to have one positive sample, we need ~3000 infected in early December.
That’s 11.5 doublings. At 3.5 days it’s 5.7 weeks, bringing patient zero to late October or later. (Doubling is probably slower at that time, so it’s even earlier, but never mind).
That perfectly matches the evidence under lab leak (Reed, Chen, the lineages in the market, and more), so the blood samples have no weight as evidence on origins.
Rootclaim's team is currently fully dedicated to teaching AI models the art of probabilistic inference, and will likely not be publishing new analyses in the meantime. If this effort is successful, we will be able to provide accurate and transparent analyses of every public controversy immediately as it happens - a service we think humanity desperately needs.
We are also in the midst of our challenge on covid vaccine safety and efficacy. Despite progressing slowly, it is nearing its end.
blog.rootclaim.com/rootclaim-acce…
Interesting updates since the Rootclaim debate on covid origins - lab leak or zoonosis?
@Rootclaim founder @saarwilf, interviewed with Destiny @TheOmniLiberal and discussed how probabilistic inference can help resolve such controversies, and how despite zoonosis winning in the debate, all evidence that came out since then completely contradicts zoonosis.
🧵Thread of the interview’s highlights:
1.2M Followers 2K FollowingFlaneur: probability (philosophy), probability (mathematics), probability (real life),Phoenician wine, deadlifts & dead languages. Greco-Levantine.Canaan. #RWRI
21 Followers 469 FollowingNeoliberal economic policy along with rugged individualism is what made the US succeed. AI will make it fall unless we make a deal with China. Lock in.
1.2M Followers 2K FollowingFlaneur: probability (philosophy), probability (mathematics), probability (real life),Phoenician wine, deadlifts & dead languages. Greco-Levantine.Canaan. #RWRI
79K Followers 606 FollowingScientist against lab-based pandemics 🧬 Co-author of VIRAL: the search for the origin of Covid-19 📖 A dangerous young investigator 🕵🏻♀
4K Followers 3K FollowingPassionate about nature, tech, and people. Backyard scientist 🔬 | Armchair genealogist 🧬 | Advocating to save lives and build a world that works.
#VaxStatRep
639 Followers 338 FollowingDad. Husband. Materials scientist. Pseudo Contractor. @OhioState & @UMich, Big pharma ask/pay you to lie? Learn about Qui Tam whistleblowing!
21K Followers 4K FollowingAuthor: We Want Them Infected: How the Failed Quest for Herd Immunity Led Doctors to Embrace Anti-Vaccine Movement https://t.co/LrW2um1R01
548K Followers 2K FollowingFormer UN Weapons Inspector, former USMC Intelligence Officer, author, analyst. Follow me on my webpages: https://t.co/cgkh5IIhOJ https://t.co/UjkJb82ulR
1.2M Followers 0 FollowingEmpowering users to create a better-informed world.
We're open source and data is publicly available: https://t.co/Te3IjR10Ix
Q? Reply/DM
634K Followers 797 FollowingInvestigative journalist. Authored over 1,800 articles on vaccine safety on my Substack. Former high tech serial entrepreneur. Founder, VSRF.
43K Followers 8K FollowingDirector of Otus @GoldenOwl_AI | Media Literacy Lecturer | OSINT · Verification & AI Detection · Information Warfare
Content is my own unless otherwise stated
151K Followers 1K FollowingWrites the UK's most popular politics Substack (https://t.co/bcjXR0ncfL).
New book - "Failed State" - now out https://t.co/uPuWlb39R3.
147K Followers 5K FollowingColumnist @WashingtonPost; Senior fellow at Georgetown University's @acmcu. Pre-order my new book CAN RELIGION SAVE DEMOCRACY? https://t.co/UjZ2W1Mp2F
85K Followers 395 FollowingStudent of causal inference, human reasoning, and history of ideas, all viewed through the sharp lens of artificial intelligence.
149K Followers 211 FollowingChallenging the herd with bold thinking in philosophy, politics and culture.
Subscribe to UnHerd here: https://t.co/zUxzdsSoTQ
380K Followers 747 FollowingComplex systems, wicked problems. Society, technology, science and more. @Princeton professor. @NYTimes columnist. My newsletter @insight https://t.co/6Ky01N9JwA
8K Followers 370 Followingח"כ מותק מרדכי (תא"ל צבא הסוכריות של מותק) מסיעת בול באמצע, זוכת המקום ה2 באח השורד הבא, נולדה ביום בו רבין נרצח ומאמינה בשקיפות מלאה על מלא. חשבון הומוריסטי
431 Followers 63 FollowingEradicate mosquitoes in your home. Bzigo is the first ever device that actively detects and locates mosquitoes. Reserve yours today at https://t.co/59ZITlKD8W
6K Followers 3 FollowingStatistically insignificant observations on data science. Submissions: https://t.co/1VcM3dRnHH omnia trahe - nihil inveniet - morietur solus
1K Followers 1K FollowingMathematician, #eDem #Consultant. My Vision: a leaderless, collaborative government. I design #VotingSystems (see my homepage).
65K Followers 5K FollowingA nonprofit news website dedicated to unlocking knowledge from experts for the public. No paywall or ads. Also now at: https://t.co/RMejHS7k1E
20K Followers 8K FollowingDirector of Gen AI @Taboola. Adjunct Professor @ubarilan School of Communication. Former #Diplomat Head of R&D Unit @ #Israel's🇮🇱 Ministry of Foreign Affairs.
214 Followers 187 FollowingProject Manager, Team Leader at Exus. Research interests: social media, big data, information retrieval and looking for more...
390K Followers 3K FollowingProf of EBM @UniOxford, author, Bad Science, more. I run https://t.co/NsF4BBoZ5V making tools+papers from data https://t.co/v6679t19rv https://t.co/bGysxEAgnn
75K Followers 193 FollowingObservations on marketing, tech and culture. The odd joke, funny mostly to myself. Views are my own. Doubt anyone else would want them anyway.